What I Should Have Said
19
What I Should Have Said · 9 of 23

Chapter Eight — — Two Days

◇

Chapter Eight

Two Days

The first day was the gathering and the conversation and the numbers exchanged. The second day was the day the context arrived.

Saad called.

Zakariya answered. Saad's voice had the quality of a person who has something to say and has already decided to say it and is simply working through the delivery.

"Nida," Saad said.

"Yes," Zakariya said.

"I know you talked to her."

"Yes."

"She is my ex. You know this."

"I know."

A pause. Then: "She is also Zara's cousin."

The second sentence landed differently from the first. Not because the family connection was new information. Because of the order in which Saad had placed it — second, as an additional weight, a complication placed on top of the existing complication.

Zakariya thought about it for the rest of the day. He thought about Nida — her specificity, the quality of her conversation, the genuine interest she had shown in what he said. He thought about whether the drawing toward her was about Nida or about the family resemblance he had noticed and filed and not examined. He was honest with himself about not knowing the answer with certainty.

He pulled back. Not cruelly, not with a formal declaration, but with the gradual withdrawal of attention that ends things before they have begun. The messages became less frequent. The frequency became silence.

It lasted two days. In the accounting of his losses, he would mark this as a failure of a different kind from Zara — not the failure of the unsaid thing but the failure of the overcomplicating mind, the mind that saw the web of connections and the potential directions of damage and chose the retreat before the complication could be faced. He would not know, for years, whether the choice was cowardice or wisdom. He was not sure, even now, that the distinction was as clean as it felt from the outside.

What he knew: he had met a person who was genuinely interesting, who had found him genuinely interesting in return, and he had walked away in two days without explanation. The walking away had its reasons. The reasons were real. They did not make the walking away feel entirely clean.

What the two days left, alongside the specific regret, was a question about his own interior that had not been clearly visible before. When you are drawn to someone, how much of the drawing is about the person and how much is about what the person represents? He had been drawn to Nida. She had her own particularity, her own interiority, her own way of being. She had not deserved to arrive in a story that was still, in some register, organized around someone else.

Syed Muhammad Hur Jaffri · The Open Manuscript